Back Link Tool Wars – AHrefs vs Majestic SEO


(An apology to email subscribers. A slight bug in the system (me) sent you this post again today instead of the new post I had planned. Sorry. I’ll do the new one tomorrow.)

PS – We’re also in the process of updating our new seo tutorial for beginners 2013.

 

The ‘AHrefs vs Majestic SEO v SEOmoz’ post on SEObook this week raised an eyebrow.

Majestic SEO, my tool of choice, has always given me enough data to kick a campaign off with, so I was surprised to see the reviewer relegate the tool to use it only for ‘mentions’ rather than back links – and because of ‘cleanup’ issues. Surprised, not least, because you can easily filter these issues in Majestic SEO before you export.

Here are some simple AHrefs vs Majestic SEO New Links discovery comparisons that were run on 15th september 2012:

Let’s see who wins…

Ding Ding

First Look at Ahrefs.com on Ahrefs. They found 48 new links

 

Ahrefs.com on Ahrefs found 48 new links

 

…whereas Majestic SEO found 187 new links to AHrefs on the same day:

 

Majestic SEO found 187 new links

 

First win to Majestic SEO

Now let’s try

Majesticseo.com on AHrefs. Ahrefs found 73 links

 

Ahrefs found 73 links

 

Whereas MajesticSEO found 406 links

 

MajesticSEO found 406 links

 

Round 2 to Majestic SEO

Hmm… 73 vs 406… Is AHrefs REALLY all it’s cracked up to be in the previous post? RBC.RU is a well known Russian site. Let’s try that…

AHrefs found 82,941 links… now that looks better…

 

AHrefs found 82,941 links

 

No… Wait… even in AHref’s own back yard MajesticSEO found 99,285 links….

 

MajesticSEO found 99,285 links

 

While AHrefs shows high counts, unless I am missing something, Majestic SEO wins 3 out of 3 in this test (albeit using a small sample).

 

Round Three to Majestic SEO

It’s worth noting Majestic SEO is a third of the price of Ahrefs and in this comparison, it wins.

The original post on seobook is here and the comments there make the post even more useful – worth a read.

What do you think is the best backlink analysis tool on the market? At the moment it’s still Majestic SEO for me.

(Sorry – wp blog comments are turned off due to tech issues)





Learn how you can get more sales from your website

Subscribe for free and let us share with you:

  • how to submit your site to Google, Yahoo & Bing
  • how to optimise your site to get more traffic from Google
  • how to target the most valuable keywords for your business
  • how to make your site rank better in free Google listings
  • how to rank high & avoid Google penalties in 2014

Trust Hobo with your SEO plan

SEO Audit